Skip to Content (Press Enter)
Skip to Footer (Press Enter)
Find a store

Buy one, get one free on select products.

Shop the sale >

Get more perks when you start your free trial of Hallmark+.

Learn more >
Get it by Halloween: Order by Thursday, Oct. 24.
Details

Classic Stuffed Animals

See previous
Large Better Together Disney Winnie the Pooh and Piglet Magnetic Plush Pair, 11"

Large Better Together Disney Winnie the Pooh and Piglet Magnetic Plush Pair, 11"

$39.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Gray Bear Stuffed Animal, 13"

Warmies Heatable Scented Gray Bear Stuffed Animal, 13"

$29.99
5
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Disney Stitch Tie-Dye Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Disney Stitch Tie-Dye Little Plush

$19.99
5" Squishmallows Sunny Yellow Honey Bee in Hat Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Sunny Yellow Honey Bee in Hat Mini Plush

$9.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Smiley Face Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Smiley Face Plush

$29.99
Large Better Together Disney Lilo and Stitch Magnetic Plush Pair, 11"

Large Better Together Disney Lilo and Stitch Magnetic Plush Pair, 11"

$39.99
8" Squishmallows Taghi White and Purple Bull Terrier Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Taghi White and Purple Bull Terrier Little Plush

$14.99
Better Together Star Wars™ Darth Vader™ and Stormtrooper™ Magnetic Plush, 5"

Better Together Star Wars™ Darth Vader™ and Stormtrooper™ Magnetic Plush, 5"

$22.99
Big Brother Dinosaur Plush, 11.5"

Big Brother Dinosaur Plush, 11.5"

$29.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Triceratops Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Triceratops Plush

$29.99
8" Squishmallows Patricia Bag of Chips Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Patricia Bag of Chips Little Plush

$14.99
8" Squishmallows Aloeene Latte Cup Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Aloeene Latte Cup Little Plush

$14.99
8" Squishmallows Gist Soda Can Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Gist Soda Can Little Plush

$14.99
5" Squishmallows Dolan Red Dino Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Dolan Red Dino Mini Plush

$9.99
8" Squishmallows Disney Stitch With Star Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Disney Stitch With Star Little Plush

$19.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Chick Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Chick Plush

$29.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Basketball Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Basketball Plush

$29.99
10" Squishmallows Peanuts Beagle Scouts Woodstock Medium Plush

10" Squishmallows Peanuts Beagle Scouts Woodstock Medium Plush

$24.99
5" Squishmallows Leif Yellow Seadragon Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Leif Yellow Seadragon Mini Plush

$9.99
Mini Baby Giraffe Stuffed Animal, 6.5"

Mini Baby Giraffe Stuffed Animal, 6.5"

$12.99
8" Squishmallows Mariska Flamin' Hot Fries Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Mariska Flamin' Hot Fries Little Plush

$14.99
8" Squishmallows Bette Light Teal Flying Fish Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Bette Light Teal Flying Fish Little Plush

$14.99
Big and Little Bunnies Plush, Set of 2

Big and Little Bunnies Plush, Set of 2

$29.99
Kitten Stuffed Animal, 7.2"

Kitten Stuffed Animal, 7.2"

$18.99
Bunnies by the Bay Hammie Pig With Piglet Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

Bunnies by the Bay Hammie Pig With Piglet Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

$44.95
Warmies Heatable Scented Narwhal Stuffed Animal, 13"

Warmies Heatable Scented Narwhal Stuffed Animal, 13"

$29.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Octopus Stuffed Animal, 13"

Warmies Heatable Scented Octopus Stuffed Animal, 13"

$29.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Llama Stuffed Animal, 13"

Warmies Heatable Scented Llama Stuffed Animal, 13"

$29.99
66
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Gray Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Gray Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

$29.95
4
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Pink Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Pink Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

$29.95
7
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Cream Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Cream Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

$22.99
6
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Kangaroo and Baby Joey Stuffed Animal and Rattle Set

Kangaroo and Baby Joey Stuffed Animal and Rattle Set

$29.99
2
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal, 20"

Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal, 20"

$49.99
11
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Stormy Blue Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

Bunnies by the Bay Little Nibble Stormy Blue Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12"

$29.95
3
4.5 of 5 Customer Rating
Demdaco Mini Giving Bear, Butterfly

Demdaco Mini Giving Bear, Butterfly

$16.99
25
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Hallmark Gold Crown Exclusive

Aurora World Palm Pals Wizard Pig Plush, 5"

Aurora World Palm Pals Wizard Pig Plush, 5"

$12.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Aurora World Palm Pals Piggles Spotted Piglet Plush, 5"

Aurora World Palm Pals Piggles Spotted Piglet Plush, 5"

$12.99
9
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Aurora Just Sayin' Merry Little Latte Plush, 10.5"

Aurora Just Sayin' Merry Little Latte Plush, 10.5"

$17.99
Better Together Candy Corn and Pumpkin Magnetic Plush, 5.5"

Better Together Candy Corn and Pumpkin Magnetic Plush, 5.5"

$16.99
36
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Aurora Palm Pals Boo Ghost Plush, 4.5"

Aurora Palm Pals Boo Ghost Plush, 4.5"

$12.99
5" Squishmallows Miriam Vanilla Cupcake Cat Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Miriam Vanilla Cupcake Cat Mini Plush

$9.99
Bunnies by the Bay Little Skipit Puppy Stuffed Animal, 12"

Bunnies by the Bay Little Skipit Puppy Stuffed Animal, 12"

$29.95
3
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Donut and Coffee Magnetic Plush, 5"

Better Together Donut and Coffee Magnetic Plush, 5"

$14.99
236
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Silver Gummy Worms Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Silver Gummy Worms Little Plush

$14.99
5" Squishmallows Benito Blueberry Cheesecake Cow Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Benito Blueberry Cheesecake Cow Mini Plush

$9.99
10" Squishmallows HugMees Aksel Pink Axolotl Plush

10" Squishmallows HugMees Aksel Pink Axolotl Plush

$14.99
5" Squishmallows Cordea Hot Pink Lobster Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Cordea Hot Pink Lobster Mini Plush

$9.99
5" Squishmallows Connor Cow Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Connor Cow Mini Plush

$9.99
Demdaco My First Teddy Bear, 6.5"

Demdaco My First Teddy Bear, 6.5"

$12.99
Demdaco Heartful Hugs Lamb Plush, 17"

Demdaco Heartful Hugs Lamb Plush, 17"

$44.00
10" Squishmallows HugMees Stevon Golden Retriever Plush

10" Squishmallows HugMees Stevon Golden Retriever Plush

$14.99
5" Squishmallows Chloe Strawberry Milkshake Poodle Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Chloe Strawberry Milkshake Poodle Mini Plush

$9.99
Bunnies by the Bay Big Hare and Little Hare Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

Bunnies by the Bay Big Hare and Little Hare Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

$64.95
Jumbo Classic Snoopy

Jumbo Classic Snoopy

$149.95
94
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Bunnies by the Bay Moo Moo Cow With Calf Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

Bunnies by the Bay Moo Moo Cow With Calf Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

$44.95
1
4.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Pocket Prayer Bear Stuffed Animal, 11"

Pocket Prayer Bear Stuffed Animal, 11"

$21.00
20
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
You’ve seen 198 of 254 products
Show more products
Loading